Carlo's Pizza 1
Casual Bite
Carlo's Pizza 2
Carlo's Pizza 3
Carlo's Pizza 4
Carlo's Pizza 5

Carlo's Pizza

Open

Cold Spring

🍕The Margherita slice is a standout
🍺Awesome beer selection to pair with
👨‍🍳Homemade sauce makes all the difference

Enormous NYC-style slices with thin, crispy crust that locals drive 40 minutes for. The homemade sauce is perfectly balanced, and the cheese pull is exactly what you want.

NYC-style pizza
Huge slices
Crispy thin crust
Homemade sauce
Google
(96)
4.7
€€€€