Mary's Candy Store 1
Casual Bite
Mary's Candy Store 2
Mary's Candy Store 3
Mary's Candy Store 4
Mary's Candy Store 5

Mary's Candy Store

Opens Friday at 5:00 AM

East Harlem, New York

🥪"flat toasty deliciousness!"
🚇"I travel from Queens just for this sandwich!"
👵Locals call it the penny store

This East Harlem bodega has been slinging griddled sandwiches for under $2 to generations of locals. The flat, toasty creations are simple but beloved enough that fans travel across boroughs for a fix.

Mom-and-pop shop
Neighborhood institution
Cheap eats
Generational favorite
Google
(25)
5.0