Sign up
New York Bakery 1
New York Bakery 2

New York Bakery

Opens Tuesday at 7:00 AM

LoMo, Philadelphia

"touchy topic" (everyonesacriticphl)
"a test of friendship" (everyonesacriticphl)
Grab a whole pie to go

Two South Philly institutions enter, one leaves crowned. Gaeta's and New York Bakery face off in a tomato pie taste test that settles the ultimate neighborhood rivalry.

Recommended by:

Instagram
@everyonesacriticphl
Google
(134)
4.9
€€€€

What are you into?

  • South Philly institution
  • Old-school vibe
  • Cash-only charm
  • Takeout only
  • New York Bakery
  • LoMo
  • Philadelphia
We use cookies

Cookies help this site function, measure usage, and support marketing. Learn more about our privacy policy.