Sign up
Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe 1
Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe 2
Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe 3
Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe 4
Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe 5
Quick Bites

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe

Open

Prospect Heights

"homemade cream cheeses...flavours I have never seen anywhere else"
Ranked #1 in Brooklyn by bagel expert Mike Varley
Ordering follows a unique loop: refrigerators → counter → cashier → pickup

The za'atar bagel here is genuinely singular: earthy, lemony, nutty, and worth the trip alone. Everything else is textbook chewy New York-style, but it's the homemade cream cheeses, with flavors you won't find elsewhere, that keep locals lining up.

Recommended by:

Mommy Poppins
Mommy Poppins
Google
(895)
4.3

What are you into?

  • za'atar specialist
  • chewy NY-style bagels
  • homemade cream cheeses
  • no frills counter
  • Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe
  • Prospect Heights

Upcoming nearby

  • KAYKA YANO PIANO SOLO

    KAYKA YANO PIANO SOLO

    Tue Nov 17, 5pm

    Williamsburg

    Solo piano in artist cafe

  • Afternoon Tea

    Afternoon Tea

    Sun Nov 22, 1pm

    Williamsburg

    Fancy French tea service

  • Tea Tasting

    Tea Tasting

    Sun Nov 29, 1pm

    Sheepshead Bay

    Rare teas & quiet ritual

  • Hush Hour: A Silent Book Club

    Hush Hour: A Silent Book Club

    Wed Dec 9, 6:30pm

    Kensington

    Silent group reading night

  • Club Cafe Series — Meet TO:NY

    Club Cafe Series — Meet TO:NY

    Sun Mar 28, 2pm

    Bushwick

    Creative backyard haven

Get picks every week

  • Fresh ideas picked for your taste
  • A little inspiration, every week