Tell me more, I’ll get better.
Sign up and I'll remember your taste, your people & your saves.
© 2026 Go Playfully Inc
Tell me more, I’ll get better.
Sign up and I'll remember your taste, your people & your saves.
© 2026 Go Playfully Inc
👨🍳"Louis... incredible part of our experience for years"
🍕Try the Wild Mushroom pizza for something different
🐟Fish preparations are the menu's strong suit
The Bay Cafe pairs waterfront views of Sheepshead Bay with Mediterranean-style fish and handmade pasta. Ask for Louis, the server regulars have been requesting for years.
Mediterranean seafood focus
Cozy waterfront cafe
All-day brunch spot
Handmade pasta
👨🍳"Louis... incredible part of our experience for years"
🍕Try the Wild Mushroom pizza for something different
🐟Fish preparations are the menu's strong suit
The Bay Cafe pairs waterfront views of Sheepshead Bay with Mediterranean-style fish and handmade pasta. Ask for Louis, the server regulars have been requesting for years.
Mediterranean seafood focus
Cozy waterfront cafe
All-day brunch spot
Handmade pasta