Hello! I'm Outgoing.I help make life more interesting.
NY Pizza Suprema 1
Pizza
NY Pizza Suprema 2
NY Pizza Suprema 3
NY Pizza Suprema 4
NY Pizza Suprema 5

NY Pizza Suprema

Garment District

This 60-year-old family pizzeria across from MSG serves classic New York slices with that perfect foldable crust, plus an upside-down Sicilian where the cheese hides under the sauce for an al dente bite. Over 50 varieties rotate through the window, but the regular cheese slice is the move that keeps locals lining up.

Family-owned since 1964
Old-school slice shop
Fast grab-and-go
Famous upside-down Sicilian

Tips

🍕"the upside-down Sicilian is on another level altogether" (Serious Eats)
🧀"Start with cheese or pepperoni. Simple slice beats the loaded pies here"
💵cash is easier — small card fee

NY Pizza Suprema

413 8th Ave, New York, NY 10001, USA

$$$$