Hello! I'm Outgoing.I help make life more interesting.
Cherry Grove Pizza 1
Italian Food
Cherry Grove Pizza 2
Cherry Grove Pizza 3
Cherry Grove Pizza 4
Cherry Grove Pizza 5

Cherry Grove Pizza

Cherry Grove

The pizza alone is worth the ferry ride to Cherry Grove, but stick around for Cacio e Pepe Carbonara and pan-roasted black sea bass at this gay-owned Fire Island mainstay.

Upscale island dining
Gay-owned restaurant
Italian-American seafood
Beachside fine dining

Tips

🍕"BEST pizza on fire island hands down"
🍰triple chocolate mousse cake is v decadent
💵cash only, come prepared

Cherry Grove Pizza

179 Ocean Walk, Cherry Grove, NY 11782, USA

€€€€