Third Time's the Charm 1
Cozy Bar
Third Time's the Charm 2
Third Time's the Charm 3
Third Time's the Charm 4

Third Time's the Charm

Opens Wednesday at 4:00 PM

Red Hook

🍕Cacio Pepe with lime? Banger!
🧄Get all the dips, especially the toum
🌿Heated backyard is perfect for lingering

A former litigator turned pandemic sourdough obsession into one of Brooklyn's most beloved pizza pop-ups, now rooted in a cozy Red Hook supper club. Wood-fired pies, playful cocktails, and a heated backyard make it worth the trek.

Sourdough pizza
Supper club vibe
Creative pies
Cozy neighborhood spot
€€€€
Book Tickets

Save lists. Chat via text. Only hear about activities you’ll love.

Sign up free